04 / Customer Economics & Cash

Their Lower Price May Be the Price of Less Work

A competitor’s bid gives you a reason to examine what your own price pays for. Start by comparing the commitments a buyer can actually enforce.

The example below is illustrative.

The $150,000 gap

A company quoted $840,000 on a multi-site implementation. The buyer awarded it for $690,000. The commercial explanation arrived quickly: the competitor bought the work. But the buyer had also agreed to a phased rollout, accepted a single report format and retained responsibility for one category of site remediation. The losing team had priced its offer as an all-at-once launch with reporting variants and more remediation risk.

The buyer may have received a better price for the same business result. It may also have accepted a different allocation of work and risk. You can investigate those explanations without knowing the competitor’s profit. Begin with your own promise and the terms the buyer has confirmed.

Normalize what the buyer bought

Build a first comparison that records only documented differences. Use bid questions, signed specifications the buyer is willing to share, contract alternatives already offered, and delivery or warranty requirements discussed with the buyer. Mark missing terms unknown. Determine who supplies each input, what “accepted” means, what happens on a late site, how service is provided and when cash is due. Compare like-for-like at a named date. A service premium is meaningful only where the buyer values the service or needs it for the stated outcome.

Then price an equivalent compliant version through your operation. Split the work into buyer-valued differences, necessary safeguards, and costs produced by your own arrangement. For instance, the same validation on two systems can be necessary when either failure could halt launch. It could be redundant if both approvals rely on identical data and catch no separate risk. Check the failure modes before removing either step.

Set a defensible bid floor

PriceScopeIncremental delivery costExpected risk costContribution after risk
$840,000Original offer$640,000$35,000$165,000
$690,000Comparable reduced offer$560,000$20,000$110,000
$690,000Original scope at the lower price$640,000$35,000$15,000

The comparable offer removes $80,000 of incremental work and $15,000 of modeled expected risk. At the same $690,000 price, matching without changing the scope therefore surrenders $95,000 of contribution. Test low-probability, severe losses separately when they would materially change who can approve the bid.

If management requires at least $100,000 contribution after the expected risk charge for this version of the job, the comparable offer clears a $680,000 project floor. If the same people could deliver a firm alternative with $130,000 of comparable contribution over the same window, the relevant threshold rises to $710,000. These are managerial decision floors for this specific job. Across a book of work, cumulative contribution must also support the fixed costs the company needs to retain. Run a downside scenario on any exposure whose expected value understates the consequence of failure.

Before you use the $95,000 difference, say where it would show up. If reporting variants rely on paid contractors, fewer variants may reduce the next bill. If the same salaried analysts would remain, less reporting may simply free analyst time. There is cash benefit when spending falls and operating benefit when the time can complete additional valuable work. A cheaper way of building the offer is commercially meaningful even before the company sees how fully it can convert that capacity. In the bid sheet, keep a conservative cost floor and record the capacity opportunity separately until a concrete use exists.

When the bids really are equivalent

Suppose the buyer confirms identical outcomes, responsibilities, acceptance standards, remedies and timing. The competitor may have a more economical delivery system. It could have different input costs, a reusable tool or underused capacity this quarter. It could also have made a bidding error. Use repeated equivalent losses and evidence from your own jobs before concluding your process is meaningfully more expensive. A single quote cannot decide the explanation.

The reverse holds too. The additional work may make the higher price reasonable because the buyer would otherwise assume volatile costs or operational risk. Quote separately for the premium promise and test whether a customer will pay for it. Some will prefer the lower-cost architecture. A comparison that allows both options can reveal more than a request to sharpen the pencil.

Review five comparable losses

For each bid, write the buyer’s acceptance condition, the terms known to be equivalent, unknown or different, the cost of those differences in your own system, your tested floor, and a competing explanation. Ask one delivery leader to identify a protection that cannot safely disappear and a cost that could be removed from the arrangement. Run the same review on recent wins. A company may repeatedly win jobs that appear premium because the bid carries work its competitors decided to price as extras.

Where the gap remains, take one repeatable workflow to the Diagnostic Standard. Use the customer operating-model analysis to decide whether the scope you want to sell and the operation you want to build agree.

Take this to your team. Which part of the price gap could you test without making a single assumption about your competitor’s margins?

← Back to Customer Economics & Cash