04 / Customer Economics & Cash

The Fee Stayed Fixed. The Scope Did Not.

A fixed fee can remain intact while successive approvals change the work, the delivery economics and the company’s ability to keep other commitments.

The example below is illustrative.

Find the first change the team could have priced

The client asked on Friday for one more creative direction before approving a campaign. The account lead said yes. The project lead could still issue the revised files by Monday. Each store had its own format, though, and the revision reopened production work after specifications had been set. By the time Finance reviewed the job, the contract price had held exactly and nobody could identify the point at which the company had accepted a different job.

Start with the last agreement both sides treated as authoritative. Establish what it allowed the customer to revise, what each approval released downstream and who could alter price, delivery date, deliverable or queue. Emails and time records can show the work. They rarely show a pricing decision unless somebody had authority to make it.

Reconcile the cost instead of pricing every hour twice

Consider a $240,000 fixed-fee project with estimated incremental costs of $148,000. Over the project, unpriced changes add $18,000 of specialist contractor work and $6,000 of overtime, neither included in the original estimate. The realized contribution on this defined basis falls from $92,000 to $68,000. The salaried team also works 280 additional hours. If its payroll would have been paid anyway, do not treat the 280 hours as a second incremental cash invoice.

Trace the 280 added hours against the schedule that existed before the scope changed. Suppose a qualified team had 160 hours of feasible work on a signed second engagement, at $150 of contribution per constrained hour after incremental costs. If the change displaces that work and it cannot be recovered elsewhere, 160 × $150 is $24,000 of foregone contribution, separate from the $24,000 in new cash outlays. The remaining 120 hours have no demonstrated alternative work and stay in the load record. In Renergy terms, the unpriced changes were dilutive where they kept paid hours from converting into Effective Capacity on the work already available. If the second engagement can move without losing contribution or displacing anything else, remove that opportunity charge. If recurring changes would instead force new staffing, model the staffing decision separately.

The underlying risk resembles the agency and marketing-services field case: protecting the relationship can have an economic cost that a fee report alone cannot reveal. The problem here is change control on the work already sold. The customer operating-model analysis covers the broader question of whether to keep granting that service model at renewal.

Define what approval allows others to do

Write a plain-language definition of the release event. In a digital project, “approved direction” could mean the client likes the concept while production cannot freeze specifications until all deliverable formats and accessibility requirements are agreed. If the same word authorizes multiple irreversible steps, the ambiguity is expensive. Give the project lead a reversible way to begin qualifying work while restricting production that requires a final specification. What Does “Ready” Authorize? works through the same problem at the handoff.

A threshold can protect speed and still catch drift. For a given service line, allow a project lead to absorb defined corrections and a small disclosed contingency. Require a documented choice when added work passes an agreed hours or external-spend threshold, moves a delivery date, reopens frozen work, or displaces a separate commitment. The customer can change the fee, remove an item, change timing, or choose to defer. A written choice is useful even when the company decides to absorb the extra work.

Make the decision owner explicit. Account can confirm whether the request changes the promise, Delivery can establish what it will consume, and a named commercial owner can revise terms or accept the economic exposure. Retain the initially authorized estimate and the revision in the same record. If the team has to start before the owner is available, specify how much reversible work can begin and who takes responsibility for the cost. That is more useful than instructing project leads to hold the line while giving them neither authority nor a workable response time.

Distinguish your error from a purchased change

Suppose the signed brief required a file format and the team implemented the wrong one. Correcting the file belongs to the existing promise; a change fee would recast a delivery failure as a customer request. Another boundary case is an engagement sold with an explicit exploration period. One more round may be exactly the experiment that was bought. Use the agreed acceptance standard and the purpose of the engagement to distinguish those cases.

If poor scoping is recurring, customer signatures are insufficient evidence that the workflow is sound. Compare consecutive projects to learn whether a specification should be collected earlier, sold in stages, or priced with a visible option. When the same “extra” appears on nearly every job, consider whether it is part of the offer the company actually sells.

Review one fixed-fee engagement

Bring the signed scope, approval history, time records and a recovery schedule into a short review. Classify each material change as correction, planned discretion or new work. Calculate avoidable cash spend, separately identify displaced contribution, and mark the person who could choose fee, scope, timing or priority at the moment of the change. Start with ten material changes. Set and test a threshold on the next comparable engagement. Check whether it reduces uncompensated changes without delaying routine corrections.

Take this to your team. At what point did the company have enough information to name the new job and give the customer a real choice about it?

← Back to Customer Economics & Cash